Architecture · Manhattan
1 Lincoln Plaza
The building that wouldn’t move

How did one old building resist demolition while everything around it changed? Find the story of stubborn negotiation in this plaza.
The story
A five-story residential building at 33 West 63rd Street, a tenement constructed in the 1890s owned by Jehiel R. Elyachar, became the target of an effort by Paul Milstein to assemble a group of properties that would become the site of 1 Lincoln Plaza. After lengthy negotiations, Milstein and Elyachar had agreed to a deal in which Milstein would acquire the property for cash, and then agreed to an exchange for a building on the Upper East Side. Though a verbal agreement had been reached, Elyachar insisted that a donation of $100,000 be made to one of the charitable organizations he supported, at which point Milstein walked away and said "You know what, you're going to keep your building". Howard Milstein, Paul's son, called the negotiations as being "among the most glaring examples of someone who overplayed their hand". The surrounding buildings on the site were demolished and 1 Lincoln Plaza was constructed around Elyachar's building at 33 West 63rd Street.
Source: Wikipedia — 1 Lincoln Plaza
Find it with City Ramble →Visiting
Wikidata coordinates; public viewing point needs field review, Manhattan. City Ramble stops can be found from public sidewalks and parks; buildings, churchyards and museums keep their own opening hours. Open in Google Maps.
Nearby
New York Society for Ethical Culture BuildingArchitecture · about 2 min walk
Edna FerberArt & design · about 2 min walk
Dante ParkArt & design · about 2 min walk
Holy Trinity Lutheran Church (Manhattan)Architecture · about 2 min walk
First Battery ArmoryArchitecture · about 3 min walk
The Century (apartment building)Architecture · about 3 min walk