Art & design · Manhattan
Astor Place Riot!
Bloodshed Over Shakespeare's Rivalry

Discover where a fierce 1849 riot erupted over two famous Macbeth productions, revealing clashes of culture, class, and national pride in old New York.
The story
On May 10, 1849, Astor Place Square witnessed one of New York City's largest riots, sparked by a bitter rivalry between American actor Edwin Forrest and English actor Edward Macready, both starring as Macbeth. This clash went beyond theater, representing ethnic and class tensions: the elite favored Macready's refined style, while working-class crowds backed Forrest's robust approach. After protests and violence, the State Militia fired into the crowd, killing around 30 people, many innocent bystanders. Macready fled to England, never to return, and the so-called 'DisAstor Place Opera House' closed, marking a turning point in New York's social and theatrical history.
Source: HMDB — Astor Place Riot! (archived 2025)
Find it with City Ramble →Visiting
HMDB marker coordinates; viewing access unverified, Manhattan. City Ramble stops can be found from public sidewalks and parks; buildings, churchyards and museums keep their own opening hours. Open in Google Maps.
Alamo (sculpture)
770 Broadway
A Tower Of Music
Astor Library
Cooper Union
428 Lafayette Street Building