Places › Manhattan

History · Manhattan

New Amsterdam Plein: Five

The Island's Unlikely Purchase and Leader

New Amsterdam Plein: Five
New Amsterdam Plein: Five · Photo: By Larry Gertner, January 23, 2004 · source
Can you find it?

Discover how Peter Minuit bought Manhattan for just 60 guilders in 1626, shaping New Amsterdam's future along with a letter serving as the city's birth certificate.

The story

Peter Minuit, an energetic and daring leader without military training, took charge of the Dutch settlers in 1626 who were scattered and troubled. Choosing Manhattan—named for “The Island” by Native Americans—as the capital, he bought it from local Indians for merely 60 guilders (about $24). While the original deed vanished, a loyal Dutch official's 1636 letter confirmed the purchase and the colony’s thriving spirit, noting their grain harvests and peaceful relations—effectively New York City's birth certificate. This simple transaction forged a gateway between Europe and America that still shapes the city today.

Source: HMDB — New Amsterdam Plein: Five (archived 2022)

Find it with City Ramble →

On our story walks

Stop 5 of 9 · New Amsterdam: the Dutch Town Under Your Feet

Legend or fact? The $24 island

Here is a story almost everyone knows: Peter Minuit bought Manhattan for $24. Is it true? The record from the time is a Dutch letter from 1626, which says the island was bought for trade goods worth 60 guilders. The $24 number came much later, from a historian in the 1800s. The letter does not even name the people who made the deal. And the Lenape thought about land differently: in their culture, the clan and the family controlled property.

Kid missionLegend or fact? Talk it over: was Manhattan really “sold” for $24? What would “selling land” have meant to the Lenape?
Legend or fact?The legend says Peter Minuit bought Manhattan from the Lenape for $24. A 1626 Dutch letter mentions goods worth 60 guilders from unnamed native people, and the $24 figure was worked out by a historian in the 1800s.

Visiting

HMDB marker coordinates; viewing access unverified, Manhattan. City Ramble stops can be found from public sidewalks and parks; buildings, churchyards and museums keep their own opening hours. Open in Google Maps.

Nearby

American Jewish Tercentenary
Food & culture · about 1 min walk
New York Unearthed / The Shrine of Elizabeth Ann Seton
Architecture · about 1 min walk
James Watson House
Architecture · about 1 min walk
John Ambrose Statue
History · about 1 min walk
1 New York Plaza
Architecture · about 2 min walk
Municipal Ferry Terminal
Architecture · about 3 min walk